FAQs
Why PRs Get Rejected

Why PRs Get Rejected

Rejection isn't failure. It's feedback.

Common Rejection Reasons

ReasonWhat To Do
Out of scopeAsk before next PR
Design disagreementOpen discussion first
Better way existsLearn the pattern
TimingAsk when to revisit
Maintainer overloadedOffer to maintain

The Feedback Loop

PR rejected

Why was it rejected?

Understand the reasoning

Adjust your approach

Next PR is better

What NOT to Do

  • ❌ Reopen immediately
  • ❌ Argue with maintainer
  • ❌ Submit identical PR again
  • ❌ Give up on the project

What TO Do

Ask: "Can you help me understand?"
Listen: "Here's why we rejected it"
Learn: "Now I understand the pattern"
Try: "How about this approach instead?"

Each rejection is a gift. It teaches you what matters to that project.